Skip to content
📖 Guides Pantry

Onions Compared: Yellow vs White vs Red vs Sweet

An empirical culinary science comparison of yellow, white, red, and sweet onions. Pungency indexes, carbohydrate profiles, moisture percentages, caramelization kinetics, and variety-specific prep protocols.

Onions
Written by: Rosa Delgado, FoxyChef recipe editor • Reviewed by: Tom Ashby, FoxyChef kitchen gear writer • Published: September 2026
Ad Disclosure: FoxyChef is an independent culinary publication supported by readers. This review contains affiliate links; when you purchase kitchen equipment or ingredients through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. All assessments reflect empirical test-kitchen trials and biochemical analysis.

Quick Answer: Choosing Between Yellow, White, Red, and Sweet Onions

Yellow onions (Allium cepa) represent the culinary benchmark for thermal reduction, braising, and long caramelization due to their dense fructan storage (4.0% to 5.5% sugars), high dry-matter ratio (88% to 90% moisture), and concentrated isoalliin content that yields rich Maillard pyrazines upon prolonged heat application. White onions feature a cleaner, sharper volatile profile with higher free moisture (91% to 93%) and minimal fructan reserves; they yield crisp crunch and immediate pungent clarity in raw Latin American salsas, ceviches, and fast wok-searing. Red onions carry moderate pungency balanced by cyanidin 3-glucoside anthocyanins; their pigments require an acidic environment (pH < 3.8) to maintain vibrant magenta hues, making them the premier candidate for raw salads, pickling, and burger toppings, but unsuitable for pale sauces where they bleed dull violet-gray tones. Sweet onions (Vidalia, Walla Walla, Maui) contain exceptionally low pyruvic acid (2.0 to 4.0 μmol/g fresh weight) and high water content (92% to 95%); their perceived sweetness stems from an absence of masking sulfur compounds rather than extraordinary sugar density, rendering them ideal for raw slicing and thick onion rings, but prone to scorching and watery stalling during slow caramelization.

Allium Biochemistry: Flavor Precursors, Pyruvic Acid, and Fructan Polymers

The organoleptic behavior of culinary onions depends on three underlying biochemical systems: sulfur-based flavor precursors, enzymatic cleavage kinetics, and storage carbohydrate architecture.

1. The S-Alk(en)yl-L-Cysteine Sulfoxide (ACSO) Cascade

Intact onion bulb cells store flavor precursors—predominantly trans-(+)-S-(1-propenyl)-L-cysteine sulfoxide (isoalliin), alongside minor fractions of S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (methiin) and S-propyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (propiin)—within the cytoplasm. In separate subcellular compartments (the vacuole), cells store the enzyme alliinase (alliin lyase, EC 4.4.1.4). When culinary preparation ruptures cell walls, alliinase immediately hydrolyzes isoalliin into unstable 1-propenesulfenic acid.

A secondary cytoplasmic enzyme, lachrymatory factor synthase (LFS), converts 1-propenesulfenic acid into volatile (Z)-propanethial-S-oxide—the volatile organosulfur compound that diffuses into ambient air, binds corneal sensory neurons, and triggers reflex tearing. Simultaneously, spontaneous condensation of sulfenic acids generates linear and cyclic thiosulfinates, dipropenyl disulfides, and trisulfides that produce the pungent, biting allium sensation on human olfactory and gustatory receptors.

2. Pyruvic Acid as an Empirical Standard of Pungency

Because alliinase cleaves isoalliin in an equimolar 1:1:1 stoichiometric ratio to produce 1-propenesulfenic acid, ammonia, and pyruvic acid, food scientists measure enzymatically developed pyruvic acid (expressed in μmol per gram of fresh bulb tissue) as the definitive quantitative measure of onion pungency:

  • Pungency Threshold < 4.0 μmol/g: Very mild to sweet. Sulfur compounds do not mask inherent carbohydrates (Vidalia, Walla Walla).
  • Pungency Threshold 4.1 to 7.0 μmol/g: Moderate pungency. Palatable in raw preparations with brief acid or water washing (Red onion cultivars).
  • Pungency Threshold 7.1 to 10.5 μmol/g: Sharp, assertive pungency. Sharp volatile sting with crisp clearing (White onion cultivars).
  • Pungency Threshold 10.6 to 14.0+ μmol/g: High storage pungency. Intense lachrymatory emission; biting sulfur aroma that requires thermal cooking to soften (Standard storage Yellow onions).

3. Carbohydrate Architecture: Fructooligosaccharides vs Simple Hexoses

Onions do not synthesize starch. Instead, their carbohydrate pool consists of simple hexoses (fructose and glucose), disaccharides (sucrose), and non-structural storage polymers called fructans (specifically fructooligosaccharides, or inulin-type chains). Yellow storage onions allocate over 55% of their total carbohydrate mass into medium- and long-chain fructans (polymerization degree DP 3 to 12). During prolonged thermal cooking (> 45 minutes at 110°C to 140°C / 230°F to 284°F), moist heat hydrolyzes these fructan chains into free D-fructose. Because fructose is about 1.7 times as sweet as sucrose, slowly braised yellow onions develop an intense, complex sweetness that raw bulbs lack.

Empirical Comparison Table

Metric / Parameter Yellow Onion White Onion Red Onion Sweet Onion
Moisture Percentage (w/w) 88.0% – 90.2% 91.0% – 93.0% 89.0% – 91.5% 92.5% – 95.0%
Soluble Solids (°Brix) 8.5° – 11.5° Brix 6.5° – 8.5° Brix 8.0° – 10.5° Brix 6.0° – 8.8° Brix
Pyruvic Acid (Pungency Index) 9.5 – 13.5 μmol/g 7.5 – 10.5 μmol/g 4.5 – 7.0 μmol/g 2.0 – 3.8 μmol/g
Dominant Carbohydrate Type Fructans (FOS) & sucrose Free glucose & sucrose Fructose, glucose & FOS Free fructose & glucose
Caramelization Onset Temp 130°C – 140°C (266°F – 284°F) 145°C – 155°C (293°F – 311°F) 135°C – 145°C (275°F – 293°F) 110°C – 120°C (230°F – 248°F)
Maillard Browning Potential Exceptional (deep pyrazines) Moderate (scorches if dry) Moderate (pigment interferes) Low-to-moderate (prone to burn)
Pigment System Quercetin flavonoids (gold) None (translucent white) Cyanidin anthocyanins (red/violet) Trace quercetin (pale cream)
pH Stability of Color Stable across pH 3.0 – 9.0 Stable across pH 3.0 – 9.0 Acid: vivid magenta; Base: gray-green Stable across pH 3.0 – 9.0
Cellular Firmness / Crispness High shear resistance Very crisp, brittle turgor Moderate-crisp turgor Soft, spongy turgor
Pantry Shelf Life (at 18°C / 64°F) 90 – 180 days (dormant) 30 – 60 days 30 – 60 days 21 – 35 days (short dormance)
Best Culinary Application French onion soup, stocks, mirepoix Pico de gallo, salsa verde, ceviche Raw salads, quick pickles, sandwiches Thick-cut battered rings, raw rings
Worst Culinary Application Delicate raw herb salads Long caramelization (turns bitter) White velouté or creamy chowder High-moisture long stock reduction

In-Depth Evaluation: The Four Primary Onion Cultivars

1. Yellow Onion (The Standard Culinary Workhorse)

Yellow onions (including cultivars such as ‘Stuttgarter’, ‘Cortland’, and ‘Patterson’) constitute over 75% of global commercial onion production. Characterized by dense, overlapping bulb tunic scales wrapped in multiple layers of papery, copper-yellow skin, they possess high dry matter (up to 12% solids) and low unbound water.

Culinary Behavior: In raw form, yellow onions deliver an aggressive, stinging bite driven by high pyruvic acid concentrations (9.5 to 13.5 μmol/g). Raw ingestion results in protracted tongue burn and persistent breath odor. However, when subjected to steady thermal processing in fat, their cell walls break down slowly, releasing fructan polymers without immediate collapse. As temperature exceeds 130°C (266°F), reducing sugars condense with free amino acids through the Maillard cascade, forming savory alkylpyrazines, 2-methylthiophene, and furans that supply foundational depth to French onion soup, beef bourguignon, and soffritto.

  • Pros: High dry-matter content prevents early pan sogginess; exceptional concentration of complex fructans produces rich, dark caramelization without added sugar; robust storage longevity (up to 6 months in cool, ventilated conditions); provides unmatched savory backbone to stocks and sauces.
  • Cons: Highly potent lachrymatory factor emissions during slicing cause severe ocular stinging; unpleasantly pungent and harsh when consumed raw in unwashed applications; requires 45 to 60 minutes of thermal reduction to express its sweet flavor profile.

2. White Onion (The Sharp, Crisp Specialist)

White onions feature pure chalk-white flesh protected by crisp, thin papery skins. Cultivars such as ‘White Grano’ and ‘Ringmaster’ are distinguished by their high tissue hydration (91% to 93% water content) and thin cellular walls with high internal turgor pressure.

Culinary Behavior: Slicing a white onion yields an immediate, sharp aromatic snap. Because white onions contain relatively low concentrations of heavy storage fructans and a clean ratio of simple reducing sugars, their flavor is bright, crisp, and incisive without the heavy, sulfurous undertone found in storage yellows. This clean sharpness finishes rapidly on the palate rather than lingering. In Mexican, Central American, and Southwestern cooking, finely diced raw white onions cut through fatty pork carnitas, rich birria broths, and rich avocados. Under extreme dry heat (such as an ungreased cast-iron comal or high-heat wok), white onions char rapidly at 230°C (450°F), imparting smoky, blistered complexity while retaining interior structural crunch.

  • Pros: Crisp, brittle mouthfeel with immediate clean flavor release; leaves minimal lingering allium aftertaste compared to yellow onions; chars beautifully on high-heat grills and planchas without collapsing into mush; essential authentic component for cold salsas, guacamole, and ceviche.
  • Cons: Prone to burning and developing bitter, acrid off-notes during prolonged low-heat sauteing; high free moisture can turn pan mixtures watery if overloaded; short storage stability (sprouts readily within 4 to 8 weeks); yields pale, flavor-deficient stocks if used in place of yellow onions.

3. Red Onion (The Raw and Pickled Specialist)

Red onions (frequently designated as purple onions) produce deep magenta outer tunic rings transitioning into pale white flesh bordered by bright crimson edges. This chromatic profile is governed by water-soluble polyphenolic pigments known as anthocyanins (predominantly cyanidin 3-glucoside, cyanidin 3-laminariobioside, and peonidin derivatives), concentrated in the outer 3 to 4 fleshy scales.

Culinary Behavior: Red onions display moderate pyruvic acid pungency (4.5 to 7.0 μmol/g) and moderate sweetness (8.0° to 10.5° Brix). When consumed raw in thin slices, they offer a crisp crunch with a mild, peppery bite that does not overwhelm raw salads, poke bowls, or burgers. However, anthocyanins are chemically reactive pH indicators. At neutral or slightly alkaline conditions (pH 6.5 to 7.8), the cyanidin structure transitions from the vibrant flavylium cation (red) to the quinonoidal base (murky blue-gray). Cooking red onions in neutral broths or braises ruptures pigment cells, leaching anthocyanins into the surrounding liquid and imparting an unappealing dingy gray appearance to light-colored dishes.

  • Pros: Striking visual presentation for raw assemblies; balanced, mild pungency that performs well without cooking; responds exceptionally to acid pickling, shifting into an electric neon-pink color; excellent texture retention when tossed with oil-based vinaigrettes.
  • Cons: Thermally unstable pigments bleed unappealing gray-purple tones into creamy soups, risottos, and light gravies; anthocyanins oxidize and fade to dull brown under prolonged boiling; relatively thin outer rings reduce usable yield during heavy trimming.

4. Sweet Onion (The Low-Sulfur Giant)

Sweet onions are regionally certified cultivars grown in geographical soils naturally deficient in sulfur (sulfate content < 20 ppm). Iconic varieties include Georgia’s Vidalia (yellow Granex hybrid), Washington’s Walla Walla, Hawaii’s Maui, and Texas 1015. Their bulbs are typically flattened (oblate) with thick, fleshy scales and high moisture content (up to 95%).

Culinary Behavior: Contrary to popular assumption, sweet onions do not contain substantially more total sugar by dry mass than yellow onions (averaging 6.0% to 7.5% sugar compared to 5.0% to 6.0% in yellows). Rather, their sweetness is an organoleptic phenomenon resulting from the near-total absence of masking sulfur compounds: pyruvic acid measures a meager 2.0 to 3.8 μmol/g fresh weight. Slicing sweet onions produces virtually no tears. Because of their higher unbound water content, attempting to caramelize sweet onions results in prolonged steaming. Once moisture finally evaporates, the high proportion of free monosaccharides (fructose and glucose) caramelizes prematurely at lower temperatures (110°C / 230°F), leading to scorching before rich, deep Maillard flavors can develop.

  • Pros: Near-zero eye irritation during prep; exceptionally mild, juicy, and palatable for raw thick slicing; produces tender, sweet onion rings when fried in batter; delicious when roasted whole en papillote with butter and thyme.
  • Cons: Highly perishable with short shelf life (2 to 4 weeks at room temperature before fungal breakdown occurs); excessive water release turns pan sauces and braises soupy; fails to build complex, savory depth in long-simmered stocks; scorches rapidly during caramelization attempts.

Drawbacks and Technical Limitations

Applying the incorrect onion cultivar across specific culinary techniques produces predictable physical, chemical, and visual failures:

  • Moisture Dilution and Thermal Stalling: Substituting sweet onions for storage yellow onions in a caramelization recipe introduces up to 7% additional unbound water. This causes the pan temperature to stall at 100°C (212°F) for 25 to 35 minutes longer as the water boils off. Once the water clears, the high ratio of free fructose burns at 110°C (230°F) before complex, savory pyrazines can form, leaving a burnt, bitter aftertaste.
  • Anthocyanin Chromatic Leaching: Using red onions in warm, neutral-to-alkaline applications (such as a creamy potato chowder, white béchamel, or risotto) triggers cellular lysis. Anthocyanins dissolve into the lipid-dairy emulsion, converting the clean white presentation into a dull, muddy purple or slate-gray hue.
  • Volatile Sulfur Bleed and Lingering Pungency: Serving raw yellow onions without a thermal step or chemical wash leaves unhydrolyzed thiosulfinates intact. These compounds coat the oral mucosa and react with sulfurous salivary proteins, causing intense burning sensations and persistent halitosis that persists for over 12 hours.
  • Structural Crumble in High-Shear Wok Cooking: Sweet onions lack the dense cellular pectin matrix found in white and yellow storage cultivars. Under high-heat stir-fry conditions (> 200°C / 392°F), their bloated, water-filled cell walls rupture instantaneously, shedding water into the wok and transforming a crisp stir-fry into an unintended braise.
  • Accelerated Spoilage and Post-Harvest Rot: Sweet and white onions lack the high concentration of fungicidal alkyl thiosulfinates and thick, suberized protective tunics found in yellow storage onions. In warm pantries (> 21°C / 70°F), sweet onions succumb rapidly to Aspergillus niger (black mold) and bacterial soft rot within 20 to 30 days.

Calibrated Test-Kitchen Bench Protocols

1. Slow Caramelization Bench Protocol (Yellow vs Sweet Onion)

This protocol assesses moisture expulsion, reducing sugar development, and browning kinetics across standard yellow storage onions and sweet Vidalia onions.

  • Standard Batch Formula: 500 g trimmed, halved, and pole-to-pole sliced onions (sliced to uniform 4.0 mm thickness); 25 g clarified butter (ghee, smoke point 250°C / 482°F); 2.5 g fine sea salt (0.5% by weight).
  • Equipment: Heavy-bottomed 30 cm tri-ply stainless steel skillet; surface infrared thermometer; calibrated precision scale.
  • Execution Steps:
    1. Preheat the skillet over medium-low heat until the pan surface stabilizes at 140°C (284°F). Add clarified butter.
    2. Add sliced onions and salt simultaneously. The salt exerts osmotic pressure, drawing intracellular water out through semi-permeable cell membranes.
    3. Stir every 3 minutes. In yellow onions, free moisture evaporates within 12 to 15 minutes, allowing pan surface temperature to rise into the caramelization and Maillard window (130°C to 140°C / 266°F to 284°F). Fructans break down progressively, creating deep amber browning with rich fond formation at minute 38.
    4. In sweet onions, excessive water release creates a continuous simmer, stalling pan temperature at 99°C to 101°C (210°F to 214°F) until minute 28. At minute 35, remaining moisture drops abruptly, and free fructose scorches against the stainless steel floor before uniform fond can be re-incorporated.
    5. Bench Conclusion: Yellow storage onions yield 182 g of uniform, deeply sweet, savory caramelized paste (yield: 36.4%). Sweet onions yield 128 g of unevenly browned, partially scorched, watery material (yield: 25.6%).

2. Anthocyanin Acid-Stabilization Protocol (Red Onion Quick Pickle)

This protocol isolates the pH equilibrium of red onion cyanidin anthocyanins, shifting them from unstable purple into durable, bright magenta.

  • Formulation: 250 g red onion, thinly sliced into half-moons (1.5 mm on a Japanese mandoline); 150 ml distilled water; 150 ml unseasoned rice vinegar (4.5% acetic acid); 20 g cane sugar; 6 g kosher salt; 2 g whole black peppercorns.
  • Execution Steps:
    1. Combine water, rice vinegar, cane sugar, and salt in a small stainless steel saucepan. Heat to 85°C (185°F) until solids dissolve completely. Target solution pH: 2.8 to 3.2.
    2. Pack raw sliced red onions into an airtight heatproof glass canning jar.
    3. Pour hot brine over the onions, ensuring complete submersion. Seal the jar immediately.
    4. Within 4 minutes, the acetic acid penetrates the cell vacuoles, protonating the quinonoidal base into the vibrant flavylium cation. The murky maroon color converts into brilliant luminescent magenta.
    5. Transfer to refrigeration at 4°C (39°F). The acidity inhibits polyphenol oxidase (PPO), maintaining crisp cell turgor and vivid pigmentation for up to 28 days.

3. Cold Emulsion & Crispness Protocol (White Onion Pico de Gallo)

This protocol utilizes high knife shear, cold water rinsing, and volatile isolation to optimize raw white onion crunch without sulfur clouding.

  • Formulation: 200 g raw white onion, diced to precision 4.0 mm brunoise; 400 g Roma tomatoes (seeded and diced); 25 g fresh jalapeño chiles (minced); 15 g fresh cilantro leaves (chopped); 25 ml freshly squeezed Persian lime juice (pH 2.2); 4 g fine sea salt.
  • Execution Steps:
    1. Dice the white onion using a razor-sharp double-bevel chef’s knife (blade edge angle 15°). Avoid dull blades, which crush cell walls and release excessive lachrymatory factor.
    2. Immediately transfer diced onions to a fine-mesh sieve and submerge in an ice-water bath (2°C / 36°F) for exactly 5 minutes. The ice water rinses away surface alliinase and volatile thiosulfinates while firming cell wall pectins.
    3. Drain thoroughly on clean paper towels. Combine firmed white onion with diced tomatoes, chiles, and cilantro.
    4. Dress with lime juice and salt immediately before service. The lime juice provides bright acid balance without softening cell wall crunch, yielding an assertive, crisp salsa with zero sulfur fatigue.

Culinary Science: Lachrymatory Mechanics and Cellular Pyrolysis

Enzymatic Kinetics and How to Stop Crying

The ocular discomfort experienced when cutting onions is a biochemical defense mechanism evolved by the genus Allium to deter herbivore predation. When knife pressure crushes onion parenchyma cells, alliinase and lachrymatory factor synthase rapidly catalyze the synthesis of (Z)-propanethial-S-oxide. Upon contact with the moisture film covering the human cornea, this gas hydrolyzes into trace sulfurous and sulfuric acids, triggering the trigeminal nerve and activating the lacrimal gland.

To mitigate this enzymatic cascade empirically, test kitchens deploy three physical controls:

  1. Thermal Depression (Chilling to 4°C / 39°F): Storing onions in the refrigerator for 2 hours prior to slicing depresses alliinase enzyme kinetics. According to the Arrhenius equation, reducing tissue temperature from 22°C to 4°C slows enzymatic conversion velocity by approximately 60%, drastically cutting volatile emission rates.
  2. Mechanical Shear Geometry (Knife Sharpness): A sharp blade ground to a 15-degree edge slices cleanly through plant cell walls, severing only the cells directly in the blade’s micro-pathway. A dull, rounded blade crushes adjacent parenchyma tissue, bursting thousands of extra cells and spraying pressurized aerosolized sulfenic droplets into the air.
  3. Water-Phase Scavenging: Slicing under an active exhaust hood or working near running water absorbs volatile (Z)-propanethial-S-oxide before the gas reaches the ocular mucous membranes.

Caramelization vs Maillard Browning in Onions

Home cooks frequently conflate caramelization and the Maillard reaction. In reality, browning onions involves both biochemical pathways operating in tandem:

1. Carbohydrate Pyrolysis (Caramelization): True caramelization is the pure thermal pyrolysis of carbohydrates without nitrogen compounds. In onions, different sugars pyrolyze at distinct critical thresholds:

  • Fructose: 110°C (230°F). Sweet onions and hydrolyzed yellow onions caramelize readily at low temperatures.
  • Galactose and Glucose: 160°C (320°F).
  • Sucrose: 160°C (320°F).

2. Maillard Reaction: As onions cook, free amino acids (such as glutamic acid and arginine) react with reducing monosaccharides via the carbonyl-amine condensation pathway between 140°C and 165°C (284°F to 329°F). This generates melanoidin pigments alongside complex volatile heterocycles—specifically alkylpyrazines (nutty, roasty notes) and alkylthiophenes (savory, meaty notes). Yellow storage onions, with their superior balance of amino nitrogen and hydrolyzable fructans, produce a savory Maillard profile that sweet onions cannot replicate.

Choosing a Pan for Caramelized Onions

The bench protocol above uses a wide, heavy tri-ply stainless skillet because it builds the browned fond that gives French onion soup its depth and can be deglazed with stock or wine as often as needed. The trade-off is that stainless needs more stirring and scraping to stop the sugars sticking. If you caramelize onions mostly as a topping for burgers, flatbreads or omelets and want less sticking and quicker cleanup, a wide, heavy nonstick skillet works at the same medium-low heat; for that case we point readers to Visit Swiss Diamond → (affiliate link). Expect less fond and a slightly lighter flavor from nonstick, and keep the burner at medium-low rather than high.

Common Execution Mistakes and Troubleshooting

  • Problem: Caramelized Onions Turn Watery, Pale, and Limp After 30 Minutes.
    Cause: Skillet overcrowding or using high-moisture sweet onions. Layering sliced onions thicker than 2.5 cm traps expelled steam, keeping the cooking environment at 100°C (212°F) and preventing surface dehydration necessary for caramelization.
    Solution: Limit onion volume to a maximum depth of 2.0 cm in a wide skillet (30 cm or larger). Maintain medium-low heat (135°C / 275°F), stir periodically to facilitate steam release, and switch to yellow storage onions.
  • Problem: Pickled Red Onions Fade to Dull Tan or Gray.
    Cause: Insufficient acid concentration in the pickling brine or using tap water with high alkalinity (pH > 8.0), which neutralizes the flavylium cation.
    Solution: Ensure brine consists of at least 50% vinegar (5% acetic acid strength) by volume. Maintain final equilibrium brine pH below 3.5. Avoid reactive aluminum cookware that catalyzes anthocyanin oxidation.
  • Problem: Raw Diced White Onion in Salsa Tastes Overwhelmingly Bitter and Harsh.
    Cause: Chopping with a dull knife or pulverizing onions in a food processor, which completely ruptures cell walls and floods the preparation with concentrated alliinase products.
    Solution: Hand-dice with a razor-sharp knife using single, deliberate draw strokes. Rinse diced onions in cold water for 60 seconds before folding into salsa.
  • Problem: Sweet Onions in Pantry Develop Black Surface Dust and Soft Necks.
    Cause: Sweet onions have high water activity (aw > 0.98) and thin, permeable skins, making them vulnerable to Aspergillus niger spores in humid ambient environments.
    Solution: Store sweet onions wrapped individually in dry paper towels inside the refrigerator vegetable crisper drawer, or suspend them in clean nylon pantyhose with knots tied between bulbs in a cool, dark, arid closet (10°C to 15°C / 50°F to 59°F).

Continue with the Right Guide

How to Use the Numbers

When applying the empirical parameters in this review, treat moisture percentages, °Brix values, and pyruvic acid concentrations as operational baselines. Agricultural factors including soil sulfur levels, seasonal precipitation, curing duration, and post-harvest storage age create natural variances across onion lots. For precision braises and commercial prep, calibrate seasoning and reduction timing against a quick pilot batch.